Four Years Is So Long. Four Years Is So Short

What is four years? Is it a long time? A short time? I have a grandson who is two. At four he will have doubled his age. It feels far away. I can imagine it, because I have experienced other four-year-olds. But it feels far away. I know this two-year old. When I think about the future four-year-old, I begin to miss this two-year-old already.

Four years is so long. Four years is so short. It has been four years since she asked me for relationship advice. Four years since she wedged herself between her mom and me during worship. Four years since she quietly held my hand. Four years since I heard her laugh or cry or sing. It feels like forever. And it feels like yesterday. Four years since my phone call went straight to voicemail. Four years since we drove to the accident. Four years since hearing every parent’s most dreaded apology—ours from a State Trooper. “I am sorry to have to tell you…” I still don’t like to type it all out, although I will never forget the sentence.

Four years since grief took up permanent residency in my heart, my home, my family. It feels like forever ago. and it feels like it happened yesterday.

And that’s another thing. Yesterday. While yesterday, September 21, is the day my sweet Ilona died, we would not find out until the early morning hours of September 22. In so many ways, that Wednesday, September 21, was the last normal day. The last day without grief. I don’t mean we had never experienced loss or sorrow or even grief, but nothing that has held such permanence.

But Wednesday was normal. Wednesday was fine. Actually, that is not quite accurate. Looking back on it with the gift that only hindsight can offer, that Wednesday was beautiful and glorious. I was still working from home, so I was there all day. Amy, a high school teacher, was getting over a mild cold but also had too many sick days that were not being used, so she decided to stay home. Ilona slept in till noon. This was her pattern when switching her sleep schedule from night-shift cardiac nurse back to normal human. She had a quiet afternoon packing for a weekend trip to visit her younger sister. At some point in the afternoon, she and both of her sisters Facetimed together. They prayed together. She told them she loved them. As she was getting ready to leave the house, her mom and I came outside to hug her and say goodbye. She had a slightly guilty “caught” grin on her face. When I looked in her Jeep, I saw my brand-new duffle bag that I had only used once. That bag sits in her room these short, eternal four years later, still packed,. Amy and I were there to say goodbye and hug her and wave until she drove away. She met a friend for Chick-Fil-A on her way to a young adult Bible study where she and her brother led the singing. While there were many “normal” days in which Ilona might not interact with any of us, this particular Wednesday she interacted with each one of us at some level. A glorious day.

That ended just after midnight. A text alert that normally would not have woken Amy but did on this occasion, “Can someone check Ilona’s location?” She should have been at Máire’s already but was still more than an hour away and still on 95. Amy called the Sherriff’s office. She called the State Police. No one had any information for us. We decided to drive to Ilona’s location. Máire and her husband had already decided on that. Amy woke our son, Jakob, to tell him what we were doing. He got up immediately and said he was coming with us. Amy continued to make phone calls the whole way. Local hospitals. Hospitals closer to her location. “Has an Ilona Bailey been admitted?” It is strange to find yourself praying that your daughter’s name be listed on an ER or ICU patient list. After silence and searching, the answer was always, “no.”

The traffic had begun flowing by the time we reached the accident. We waited on the side of the highway for a trooper to come speak with us. God spared us from seeing her car. Then the dreaded apology. We wept. We wailed. The sound of Jakob’s wailing is indelibly scarred into Amy’s memory. It was impossible. It was unfathomable. We had so many we had to call. First her sisters. I still shudder today when I think of how poorly I handled it with Máire. Rae was living in Lynchburg. Amy called her. After she told her, she simply said, “Rae, come home.”

We got home around 3 am. More phone calls. Family. Friends. Church leaders. Although the calendar will tell you that the 21st to the 22nd of September is the autumnal equinox where light and dark exist in equal measure, I will tell you that that was the longest, darkest night of my life. It lasted for days. Months. Maybe a year. It still casts its shadow regularly. It is the new normal.

I used to think that grief was like waves in an ocean. Normally calm, but occasionally turbulent. A body of bliss with the occasional interruption of sorrow. Sometimes the waves are manageable, other times they come in like a hurricane and threaten to pull me under.

I’ve begun to wonder if grief is not the waves, but the water. Grief, loss, these are the norm of existence now, the waves are occasions of grace and joy. Sometimes they are subtle lifts—moments of laughing with Amy at silly memories, sitting with friends over cigars or beverages. Other times they are loud crashing waves of goodness—weddings, grandchildren, the rare times we are all together as a family… all together save one.

Some might wonder if I am not defining myself by my loss. By my grief. I don’t think so, but it is a fair question. I think there is a difference between defining oneself by loss and recognizing that the loss has changed you.

I have a cold right now. It’s a bad cold. I rarely get sick so it is annoying. I fully expect that by the end of this week or at worst next week, this cold will be a thing of my past. It would be strange and unhealthy to continue to dwell on how uncomfortable and irritable I was two weeks ago when I had a cold. It would be strange to remind friends and family members about the cold I had two weeks ago.

But if I had recently had an arm amputated, it would be hard not to admit that it was going to have a profound and ongoing impact on my life and living and relationships. Then the unhealthy approach would be acting as if my life was ever going to be exactly the same as it was before the loss. You would even encourage me that it was not a worthy or realistic goal.

Grief is more like an amputation than a head cold. I don’t have to define my life by it, but I cannot pretend it has not changed me significantly.

I think this is at least in part what Paul speaks of when he says in 1 Thessalonians 4. “And now, dear brothers and sisters, we want you to know what will happen to the believers who have died so you will not grieve like people who have no hope” (New Living Translation).

It is not that we should not grieve, but that we need not grieve like those who have no hope. Grief is real. We do not need to deny it or try to temper it or rush through it as if it’s just a phase like teething. We are not hopeless in our grief, but we are in grief. I know that my grief is for me. For my dear wife and my children. For our families and Ilona’s friends. We have suffered a great loss. I know that Ilona is beyond death and disease and sin and suffering. She is at home with her Lord. I may have many questions about what that looks like, but I know for certainty she is beyond grief and sorrow.

These are some thoughts and ideas four years in the forming. Certainly not everything I’ve been thinking but at least where I have been these last two days.

New Years are harder

December 31, 2025

For anyone grieving the death of a loved one, there will always be those expected difficult days throughout the year. Ilona’s birthday is hard – August 29. The day of Ilona’s death is hard – September 21. Holidays that focus on family bring a weight and an empty seat with them now – Thanksgiving, Christmas.

For widows and widowers, that list includes wedding anniversaries. For children who have lost parents too soon (and when is it not too soon?) their own birthdays can be hard.

But for many who are grieving, there are also those unexpected difficult days. These can be random unscheduled days that don’t show up on the calendar but sneak up on the heart through a memory or a sight or a smell. But some days are calendar days that, after the first one is experienced, become difficult days every calendar year.

For me New Year’s Eve in 2022 was excruciating. I was leaving the last calendar year I would ever share with my beautiful daughter, Ilona. I was about to enter an entire year, twelve whole months, 365 consecutive days, without Ilona. Every time I would realize this for the three days leading up to New Year’s Eve and especially on New Year’s Eve I would weep.

As the fourth New Year’s Day without Ilona approaches, I do not weep every time I think about it, but I think about it constantly, and I sit on the edge of tears. I know that there are good things coming in 2026. I know that there is much to look forward to and much to thank God for. I know that God will continue to guide, guard, carry, and care for me through the next year.

In the past I have chosen to reflect on Psalm 90 as the new year approaches. It is still the psalm I turn to at the end of every December, though the line about living seventy or eighty years rings differently now. But the psalm is a reminder that if the steadfast love of God is not the source of my joy, my joy is fleeting and full of toil. We are reminded to number our days aright—a number we do not know and should not—so that we keep a healthy perspective on what is, what was, and what may or may not come.

If you have loved ones facing loss and grief, ask them – Is there an unexpected hard day that springs up occasionally or annually? Ask for stories about their loved one. Enter into the sacred space of love unexpressed. Give a sympathetic ear, an open heart, a silent presence. Or share your own memories of their loved one. Be willing to laugh and to cry and give them freedom to laugh and to cry. Remind them, “You are not alone. We will not forget.”

New Year’s Eve, 2020, with Cleveland cousins.
Coffee run the following year on New Year’s Day, 2022.

Psalm 90:12–17

              So teach us to number our days

                             that we may get a heart of wisdom.

              Return, O LORD! How long?

                             Have pity on your servants!

              Satisfy us in the morning with your steadfast love,

                             that we may rejoice and be glad all our days.

              Make us glad for as many days as you have afflicted us,

                             and for as many years as we have seen evil.

              Let your work be shown to your servants,

                             and your glorious power to their children.

              Let the favor of the Lord our God be upon us,

                             and establish the work of our hands upon us;

                             yes, establish the work of our hands!

Advent – Christmas Day – Four Advents Later

When Advent seems to bring as much heartache as joy, maybe more

Christmas Morning

   After you have suffered a little while,
   May the God of all grace,
   Who has called you to his eternal glory in Christ,
   Restore you,
   Confirm you,
   Strengthen you,
   and Establish you.
   To him be dominion forever and ever.
   Amen.
–1 Peter 5.10-11

This is the benediction I pronounced at the end of Ilona’s funeral.  I wanted very much to be able to write something from a place of restored strength.  It seems I am still suffering a little while longer however.  The personal notes many have sent have been a help.  Thank you.  I know what God can do, because I know what God has done (the hope Psalm 77 ends with).  I know that this brief leg of my journey will be more blurred with tears than I anticipated before I finally reach the gray havens.  I know that the birth of this babe we worship today was the death knell of death and darkness. 

I leave you with two things, neither of which I wrote.  The first, a poem I post every Christmas by Robert Southwell, This Little Babe.  The second, a post my daughter Ilona wrote early Christmas morning last year as she served in the cardiac unit of the hospital on her night shift. 

This little Babe so few days old
is come to rifle Satan’s fold;
all hell doth at his presence quake
though he himself for cold do shake;
for in this weak unarmèd wise
the gates of hell he will surprise.

With tears he fights and wins the field,
his naked breast stands for a shield;
his battering shot are babish cries,
his arrows looks of weeping eyes,
his martial ensigns Cold and Need
and feeble Flesh his warrior’s steed.

His camp is pitchèd in a stall,
his bulwark but a broken wall;
the crib his trench, haystacks his stakes;
of shepherds he his muster makes;
and thus, as sure his foe to wound,
the angels’ trump alarum sound.

My soul, with Christ join thou in fight,
stick to the tents that he hath pight.
Within his crib is surest ward,
this little Babe will be thy guard.
If thou wilt foil thy foes with joy,
then flit not from this heavenly Boy.

Disappointed Expectations or Beyond Anything I Could Have Expected?
–Ilona Bailey (August 29, 1999 – September 21, 2022)

12/25/21 12:57 am

Christmas morning. It looks a little different this year. Instead of cozied up in my warm bed, I find myself in the hospital, caring for people who are unable to care for themselves.

I’ve had a lot of trouble getting into the Christmas spirit this year. My focus has been off. My sleep schedule is wack. My energy is low. And I’ve definitely been moody. I haven’t been able to go to church regularly because of work. I have listened to Christmas music on maybe two occasions. Joy suddenly becomes more of a choice than an easy feeling. Contentment is something I need to work at.

And then, three days ago, my family was struck with disappointment. My brother tested positive for COVID. He came home from Lynchburg and immediately retreated to the basement. Suddenly, Christmas plans were being derailed. I know that each of my family members, including myself, were privately grieving the loss of our Christmas expectations. How could I possibly celebrate during a time like this?

But as I sit here and reflect on the past month, I can’t help but see God’s faithfulness. I have been working and learning and growing. I have been able to be a light to complete strangers. I have had the chance to serve and care for and protect patients. It’s been hard. But I have left work every single day being reminded that God is with me, even on the hard nights.

There are a lot of things in this life to be disappointed about. This world is fallen and broken. But isn’t that why we celebrate Christmas? Our Lord saw the brokenness and didn’t turn away. Jesus willingly humbled himself to be born as a baby, to live a perfect life in a broken world, and to die a painful death. He bore the wrath of God for me, so that I could spend eternity with Him.

So, maybe the Christmas spirit is hard to find this year. But that’s precisely why there is a “true meaning of Christmas” after all. Because this broken world needs saving. And that’s just what we have received in Christ. Hope and joy beyond anything we could have expected.

And in the same region there were shepherds out in the field, keeping watch over their flock by night. And an angel of the Lord appeared to them, and the glory of the Lord shone around them, and they were filled with great fear. And the angel said to them, “Fear not, for behold, I bring you good news of great joy that will be for all the people. For unto you is born this day in the city of David a Savior, who is Christ the Lord. And this will be a sign for you: you will find a baby wrapped in swaddling cloths and lying in a manger.” And suddenly there was with the angel a multitude of the heavenly host praising God and saying, “Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace among those with whom he is pleased!”
–Luke 2:8-14

this is the song I sang at Ilona’s funeral, and one of my favorites by the Gray Havens

Four Advents Later

I love this post. I read Ilona’s writing every Christmas to myself. I need to add it to the family readings in the morning. Yesterday was a day overflowing with blessing and love. God is always faithful. He has been kind beyond our deserving. Christmas is an opportunity to celebrate his kindness and remember his presence and bless each other. We are so blessed. We will miss Ilona terribly until we see her again. But we are certain that because of Christ, we will. Come quickly, Lord Jesus!

Advent Day Twenty-Four – Four Advents Later

When Advent seems to bring as much heartache as joy, maybe more

A Sword Has Pierced My Soul

And Simeon blessed them and said to Mary his mother, “Behold, this child is appointed for the fall and rising of many in Israel, and for a sign that is opposed (and a sword will pierce through your own soul also), so that thoughts from many hearts may be revealed.”
–Luke 2.34-35

Not the Picture Perfect Delivery

Three weeks before Amy’s due date, in late August of 1999, Amy and her mother (who was with us helping us care for a three-year-old girl and a twenty-month-old boy) both came down with the flu.  The exhaustion and dehydration caused Amy to go into labor in the middle of the night.  Even though Amy was exhausted and recovering from the flu, a little after 8:00 in the morning, Ilona Adaline was born.  She had a full head of black hair that would be replaced with blond over her first several months.  It felt like we had survived an ordeal.  The next day in a routine checkup, the doctor discovered that because Ilona was three weeks early, her hip joints had not developed properly.  When we were discharged we were sent directly to an orthopedic pediatrician so that Ilona could be fitted with a brace that she would wear for the first two months of her life.  Even though this was our third child, it was a lot to take in for these 28-year-old parents.  To make matters more overwhelming, Amy’s mother slipped in the hospital parking lot when they came to visit us and meet Ilona.  She shattered her elbow and would need surgery.  They had to go back to Cleveland as soon as Amy and Ilona were discharged.   When they left Amy sat, holding our sweet Ilona in her leg brace and wept.

Everyone dreams of the perfect pregnancy and the perfect delivery of their perfect baby.  But there are always little reminders that this world is not perfect.  This world is broken.  I think about Mary and her pregnancy. 

Not ideal for a teenage Jewish girl to have to announce to her future husband, to her family, to her village that she is pregnant.  I think about the journey forced on them by Caesar Augustus.  I wonder if that difficult journey put her into labor.  Now she would give birth in Bethlehem, a strange town and a strange house, not at home with her mother where most normal births occurred.  Her first baby, a perfect (no, really… perfect) baby boy, would have to be laid in a feeding trough for animals, because the home they were in didn’t have any room for them anywhere else.  When the time for the purification sacrifice, they didn’t make enough money to afford a lamb so they had to settle for two pigeons instead.  Mary knew the promises that had been made to her about this child, but this was a strange way for those promises to begin.  But the world is broken and even Jesus was born into a broken world.

Not the Picture-Perfect Parents

When her big brother was learning how to ride a bike, Ilona’s dad released him down the cul de sac on a direct path with her on her tricycle.  The collision knocked out her front tooth and contributed to her cute gapped smile that would last into middle school braces.  Parents aren’t always the most attentive in this broken world.

“Did I ever tell you about the time I lost the Son of God?” I wonder if this is how Mary told Luke and the others about the near fiasco at the temple.  How long was he missing?  Three days?!  Why didn’t they think to look in the temple?  What parent hasn’t scolded her child when the mistake was the parent’s all along?  We parents are too often a good reminder that this world is broken.

They Grow In Spite of Our Efforts

Ilona would grow in wisdom and stature.  The one area she and her Savior differed (other than the obvious sinner part) was that she had so much beauty and dignity that many were attracted to her. 

She was a friend that could be trusted with the deepest secrets and longings of your heart, and she would take them directly to her Father in heaven.  She was a compassionate nurse who loved to care for those who could not care for themselves.  She loved her family and her friends and just wanted to see all of them have the same relationship with God that she did.  We watched God keep his covenantal promises to us as she delighted in Him and had a faith that caused us all to look on in wonder.

As Jesus grew in wisdom and stature, he showed himself to be a friend that could be trusted, even with fears and doubts, and he would pray for his friends, he would point them to the faithfulness of a Father in heaven who delights to call us his children.  Jesus was a compassionate healer who came to care for those who could not care for themselves.  He loved his family and his friends and wanted them to have the same relationship with his heavenly Father that he did.  God was keeping his covenant promises to the world through Jesus.

But this world is broken. 

Because this world is broken, the death of Jesus was necessary.  Because this world is broken, the death of Ilona was inevitable.  “It is appointed for every person to die once and then face judgment” (Hebrews 9.27).  But knowing the inevitability of death did not prepare my heart for Ilona’s.  I was not ready.  It was not right.  My very soul has been pierced.  No less than Mary’s.  Just because the death of Jesus was necessary, that did not make it easier for his mother to watch, to accept.  As John Calvin put it when commenting on this passage, “Even if she was not overwhelmed with grief, it would have required a heart of stone not to be deeply wounded: for the patience of the saints differs widely from stupidity.”

And while there is the comfort of knowing that Ilona, like the repentant thief on the cross, is right now this very day with Jesus in paradise, there is still this gaping wound in my soul.  And though it may over time become less raw, it will never fully heal until that day, that glorious resurrection day, when communion with Christ will be perfected and the reunion of the saints will be forever. 

And just as it is appointed for man to die once, and after that comes judgment, so Christ, having been offered once to bear the sins of many, will appear a second time, not to deal with sin but to save those who are eagerly waiting for him. –Hebrews 9.27-28

Four Advents Later

As we prepare for the fourth Christmas Eve and the fourth Christmas Day, the house is full. Our grandson is running around with two dogs and his Daddy, screaming with glee. the kids are finishing last-minute Christmas needs. Gifts are getting wrapped. We will get ready for the candlelight service later tonight. Ilona’s boyfriend who would have been her husband will join us at the service and back at home tonight. We will laugh and play games together. And we will remember fuller Christmases, and dream of Christmases that will not be. Amy and I will take a meal to the nurses working the night shift in the cardiac wing where Ilona worked–where she was working the last Christmas Eve we had together.

The thing is, we will celebrate. After all, the point, the purpose, the reason there is a Christmas is that God sent his Son to be born in order to die. So that we, deserving and facing inevitable death, might live. Ilona knew this.

Advent Day Twenty-Three – Four Advents Later

When Advent seems to bring as much heartache as joy, maybe more

God Groans

For the creation was subjected to futility, not willingly, but because of him who subjected it, in hope that the creation itself will be set free from its bondage to corruption and obtain the freedom of the glory of the children of God.  For we know that the whole creation has been groaning together in the pains of childbirth until now.  And not only the creation, but we ourselves, who have the firstfruits of the Spirit, groan inwardly as we wait eagerly for adoption as sons, the redemption of our bodies.  For in this hope, we were saved. Now hope that is seen is not hope. For who hopes for what he sees?  But if we hope for what we do not see, we wait for it with patience.

Likewise, the Spirit helps us in our weakness. For we do not know what to pray for as we ought, but the Spirit himself intercedes for us with groanings too deep for words.  And he who searches hearts knows what the mind of the Spirit is, because the Spirit intercedes for the saints according to the will of God.
–Romans 8.20-27

Anyone suffering at all during the Advent season knows the “no duh” realities of the first two points Paul makes here: The world is broken, and the brokenness is not theoretical but personal. 

Creation is a slave to corruption.  Addictions, Depression, Abandonment, Abuse, War, Murder, Hate, Death.  There is so much wrong.  Everything about this world is a rat race of futility.  Creation groans, Paul says.  Not like an old house, creaking and settling, but like a woman in labor.  We have had four children.  There is nothing quaint or sentimental about the painful groans and sometimes screams during labor.  This is how creation groans.  She wails for deliverance, for redemption.  “Make it stop!”

And we groan.  Not a day goes by that my house is not a household of tears, sometimes alone and quiet, sometimes weeping and groaning together.  There is a physical heaviness to our grief.  Amy feels it on her shoulders, as if she is carrying a burden she cannot put down.  I feel it in my chest, like someone has rested a kettlebell on my heart and I cannot lift it. 

I left out the opening sentence to the paragraph above, “I consider that the sufferings of this present time are not worth comparing with the glory that is to be revealed to us.”  It is hard to imagine such blissful glory and joy that it makes our current pain not worth even mentioning.  I try to remind myself that this glory, this deliverance, Ilona is tasting even deeper right now.  My tears have never been for her, for what she’s missing, but for us, what we are missing. 

Those are the “no duhs” of the passage: the world is broken, and it hurts.  This does not bring a whole lot of comfort.  But that is not the end of the groaning.  Yes, the world is groaning.  Yes, I am groaning.  But God is groaning also.  The brokenness of our situation causes the Spirit of God himself to groan with us and for us.  And he is not just groaning into the darkness the way I do so often.  He is groaning in prayer on my behalf to my Father.  The Holy Spirit is praying for me.  The Holy Spirit is praying for my wife.  The Holy Spirit is praying for my children.  When I have no idea what to ask for or what to say, the Holy Spirit is praying for me.  When I feel like all I do is groan before God, I take comfort knowing that sometimes, that is all the Holy Spirit is doing also.  He groans for me, for my family.  He groans for you. 

Four Advents Later

Admittedly, one reason I chose this “revisit and rethink” path for the Advent writings this year is these last three days. Last year I wrote on the 23rd, and then stopped. On Christmas Eve last year, we did our normal Christmas morning traditions, because two of our kids were spending actual Christmas with their in-laws. It made for a sweet Christmas Eve morning and a chaotic Christmas Eve afternoon and evening as we tried to fit in Christmas dinner before heading to church early to set up and prepare for the Candlelight service. So, I did not really have time to think about a new post Christmas Eve last year. And on Christmas Day, I did not have the energy.

Christmas morning came. I woke early, as I have done since I was a child every Christmas morning. But this time for no apparent reason. Our oldest was sleeping in. Two were gone, and with them, their spouses and our less-than-one-year-old grandson. The presents (and presence) and chaos in the living room was gone. And the house was overwhelmingly, deafeningly, infuriatingly silent. And I sat at the kitchen table and wept. I said to Amy through tears, “This is the rest of our lives!” There has been a moment like that every Christmas so far these past three Christmases and I expect another one in two days and for many, if not all of our remaining Christmases until Christ comes a second time. It is almost impossible to describe because it is not imaginable – a missing child at your Christmas celebrations. It is incredible to think at these moments, that God prays for me. The Holy Spirit groans and intercedes for me. Later in the same chapter in Romans, Paul will remind us that Jesus Christ intercedes for us. Two-Thirds of the Trinity are praying for you always, but especially in the broken groan-worthy moments of life. What an incredible help. What an incredible consolation. What an incredible God.

Advent Day Twenty-Two – Four Advents Later

A Darker Advent than Desired

When Advent seems to bring as much heartache as joy, maybe more

An awful exchange

Look to Jesus, the founder and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising the shame, and is seated at the right hand of the throne of God.
–Hebrews 12.2

At many Advent and Christmas parties it is popular to hold a gift exchange, but with a twist.  Whether you call it white elephant or Yankee swap or dirty Santa, the idea is the same.  Bring a bad gift and hope to exchange it for, if not a good gift, at least a less bad gift. My youngest took this so seriously one year that she wrapped a dead rat.

Our advent this year feels like a nightmare version of this.  We have exchanged the joy of Ilona and the light of our family gatherings for the sorrow of Ilona’s death and the shadow that covers our gatherings now.  It is such a bad exchange that the only words appropriate for it are not appropriate for some audiences. 

It is not an exchange we wanted.  This is not a path we want to be on.  It is not a path we would wish on anyone.  Less than one month after Ilona’s death we were at my nephew’s wedding.  Amy was able to speak with a woman whose daughter had died at only twelve years old.  It was a help for Amy.  One thing this woman said, however, was that she now looks for ways and knows better how to care for others who are walking this dark path.  That night Amy said to me in tears, “This is not the ministry I wanted.”

This is so hard to explain without risking offense.  I have written these advent readings primarily for my family.  I want them to know that it is ok not to be ok.  I want them to know that the light is shining even when we can’t see it, that Christ is leading us even when we can’t walk, that the Spirit is groaning with us even when we can’t hear him, that God is holding us even when we can’t feel him.  I have put these thoughts on my blog so that I would be held accountable to write each day.  So many have shared that these have been a help to them, and I do not want that to stop.  But there is a large part of me that hates that this is the help I am now. 

I am reminded of Gandalf’s words to Frodo who also wished things had not turned out the way they had.  “So do all who live to see such times, but that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to us.”

I am humbled and awed that this is the very exchange Jesus made for me.  In exchange for the joy that was before him he endured death—the cross—even though he despised, hated, the shame of it.  The Son of God had perfect love and union and communion with the Father and the Spirit.  Their relationship lacked nothing, needed nothing, wanted for nothing.  And yet in exchange for that he endured the cross—a symbol and instrument of sin and darkness and hatred and death.  It is another passage that reminds me that Jesus despises what sin and Satan have done to this world.  He hates death.  He despises that Ilona had to die.  He despises that we must suffer such loss and sorrow and mourning and grief in this world.  He will do away with it all one day.  He will himself one day come back and make his home with us again.  This time to be with us forever; to wipe every tear out of our eyes for good; to do away with the despised enemies of God, death, mourning, crying, pain—they will all be destroyed. 

These are hard truths to call to mind in the valley of the shadow of death. 

Four Advents Later

While it is still true, this is not the ministry we would choose or ever thrust upon someone else, after three years and four Advents I can say that Amy and I are humbled and overwhelmed by the doors that have opened for us to step through and minister. Last year we started a monthly bereaved parents gathering. we meet with other parents who have faced the unimaginable tragedy of burying a child. There are six families that come regularly and others who come occasionally. four of those families came to the Longest Night service last night. All of them in, or just weeks past, the first year of loss. As I read these posts from three years ago, I remember the fog, the void, the weight on my chest, the inability to think of much else.

Today we had supper together as a family with sweet friends who have walked with us through all of this. We met after the women spent the afternoon dress shopping for our oldest who will be getting married in May. It was a sweet evening. It sounds like it was a sweet day for the women. It is often only at the end of the day, when all quiets down, that the heart begins to think of the one missing. Ilona would be so happy for my oldest. She prayed constantly for her sister. She loved her dearly, and only wanted to see her thriving in God’s love. We will continue to miss her and grieve these secondary losses for the rest of our lives. The joys of the moments are not diminished, but there is a companion to joy now. the joy and the sorrow coexist. Both are present. Sometimes one leads and the other fades to the background. But both are always present now.

Advent Day Twenty-One – Four Advents Later

A Darker Advent than Desired – day 21

When Advent seems to bring as much heartache as joy, maybe more

The Darkest Day of the Year

We were so utterly burdened beyond our strength that we despaired of life itself.  Indeed, we felt that we had received the sentence of death. But that was to make us rely not on ourselves but on God who raises the dead.
–2 Corinthians 1.8-9

“O my son Absalom, my son, my son Absalom! Would I had died instead of you, O Absalom, my son, my son!” –2 Samuel 18.33

I don’t know what to write today.  This is the three month… what… anniversary? The 21st and 22nd are both very difficult days for us.  We would not learn about Ilona’s death until 1:15 in the morning.  The 22nd was the longest darkest day of our lives. 

This was exactly one year ago on this day. We were shopping with these two when we learned that our son had COVID. We sat in a store and wept over the changes that would have to come to our celebration. What would I give for that trial instead of this one?

Paul’s words are so painfully accurate.  I am so utterly burdened beyond my strength.  My dear sweet wife and remaining children are the only things keeping me from despairing of life itself.  I know that my only hope is in a God who raises the dead, but my heart is refusing that comfort right now. 

Today is the winter solstice, which means that where I live in the northern hemisphere, it is the darkest day of the year.  I feel that today.  From this day on until the next solstice in June, we will gain between 90 and 150 seconds of sunlight each day.  An average of two more minutes of light every day for the next six months. 

I am told I too will have that one day.  Something will change.  The darkness will begin to lift.  I will be able to see the light.  I will be able to receive the comfort of a loving heavenly Father.  There will still be darkness and sorrow and grief, but the light will grow stronger and brighter and not be overcome by the darkness.  That day has not yet come.  For now, I live in an ongoing solstice of more dark than light.  The light is here.  I can see it.  I know that it is true and the only place I am going to find comfort, but the sun sets too early each day.  I can’t stay in the light.  Darkness returns and feels like it is trying to move in permanently.  I am left crying out like King David in agony, “O my daughter Ilona, my daughter, my sweet daughter Ilona! Would I had died instead of you, O Ilona, my little girl, my baby!”

I have no power to make this darkness abate.  I cannot fake the brightening sky.  And it would be ridiculously unhealthy to do so anyway.  Today, I must wait.  I must learn to rely entirely on God and to wait.

There was a time when Amy and I thought that we could handle, with God’s help, anything God threw our way.  That was a lie.  We were deceived.  We cannot handle this.  We don’t need a little help from God.  We need God.  It is not us and God in partnership.  It is not our elbow grease and God blessing our efforts.  It is not even us learning what we need to so that God can bless us.  It is God or not at all. 

Four Advents Later

Today is three years and three months. Three years and three months ago tonight was truly the darkest night my family and my soul have been asked to face. Interesting that it was the autumnal equinox, and that the light was growing less and less with every passing day.

I reread this entry from three years ago and am overwhelmed by God’s carrying us. While we are still overwhelmingly sad and some moments hit so unexpectedly hard (I almost had to leave the worship service today as the children’s choir sang so beautifully to God, “Joyful, Joyful, We adore Thee!”). And yet I can see that in some ways something has changed. We do have more hope than we did three years ago. We can rejoice in the good gifts of God, even when those good gifts remind us of Ilona’s absence. We can see God’s carrying and sustaining grace through all of this, even if we would have preferred a delivering and avoiding kind of grace. We can sing of God’s goodness and kindness and mercy, even as we wait for the final perfection of his goodness when he puts death to death.

Tonight is our first Longest Night Advent Service. I m not sure what to expect from the service. Some of the families from our bereaved parents group will be there, I think. Beyond them, I know there are so many in just our small congregation that are mourning things this season. I want the service to be a comfort and a help and above all, point to the only hope that sustains through devastating loss, the hope of Jesus Christ, who came down to take on our sorrow and pain and sin and be the Savior of the World.

Advent Day Twenty – Four Advents Later

A Darker Advent than Desired – Day 20

When Advent seems to bring as much heartache as joy, maybe more

He does not afflict from his heart

He has walled me about so that I cannot escape;
      he has made my chains heavy;
   though I call and cry for help,
      he shuts out my prayer;
   he has blocked my ways with blocks of stones;
      he has made my paths crooked.
–Lamentations 3.7-9

   He has made my teeth grind on gravel,
      and made me cower in ashes;
   my soul is bereft of peace;
      I have forgotten what happiness is;
   so I say, “My endurance has perished;
      so has my hope from the LORD.”
–Lamentations 3.16-18

No real reason for this pic, other than, I love my kids.

The closer Christmas gets, the harder it is on my soul.  And also, the more real and desperate I feel the need for God to break into the darkness and rescue us. Rescue me.  The book of Lamentations has always been a favorite for Amy and me.  It is real.  It is raw.  A collection of five poems/songs written by the weeping prophet, Jeremiah.  It contains reminders that God alone is our hope in darkness.  But it also contains anguishing cries that, if they were not recorded in Scripture, would seem borderline blasphemous if not at least disrespectful.

In the sections above is the hard acknowledgment that God has done this.  God is in this.  The same God who caused our lines to fall in pleasant places (Psalm 16.6) is the God who has made our path crooked for the time being.  I cower in the ashes and feel as if my soul has been robbed of peace.  I won’t go so far as to say that I have forgotten what happiness is.  I can laugh with family still (Jakob’s birthday was a wonderful gift of that).  I can laugh with friends or just sit with them.  I can even enjoy the quiet evenings on the couch with my wife, but there is always an uninvited shadow, a wraith, a monster looming. I feel like my life is a choose-your-own-adventure book and turning the wrong page will bring unexpected tears and sorrow all over again. 

   Remember my affliction and my wanderings,
      the wormwood and the gall!
   My soul continually remembers it
      and is bowed down within me.
   But this I call to mind,
      and therefore I have hope:

   The steadfast love of the LORD never ceases;
      his mercies never come to an end;
   they are new every morning;
      great is your faithfulness.
   “The LORD is my portion,” says my soul,
      “therefore I will hope in him.”
–Lamentations 3.19-24

Remembering the affliction, the bitterness is as easy as breathing.  Jeremiah says “My hope from the LORD has perished.”  But he immediately goes on, “wait.  That’s not quite right.”  That is what it feels like.  It feels as if since my peace and happiness are gone (verse 17) then my hope must be gone as well (verse 18).  When all I can see is the darkness and all I can feel is the shadow and all I can hear are the monsters, then I can easily assume that all hope is gone.  I must tell myself the true story.  I must remind myself that the child has come and defeated the monsters.  I must call things to mind and heart that used to come more easily: because the steadfast love of the Lord never ends and his mercies come new every morning, I can hope again.  Hope not in what I feel or see but hope in what I cannot see (Hebrews 11.1).  Amy and I used to say, sometimes amusingly, that it’s a good thing God’s mercies are new every morning, because sometimes I feel like I’ve burned through them before I’ve finished my first cup of coffee.  There is nothing amusing about it anymore.  I need new mercies from God every morning that I face without Ilona.  I need his reminder that his faithfulness has not ended, that he is still my portion.

   For the Lord will not
      cast off forever,
   but, though he cause grief, he will have compassion
      according to the abundance of his steadfast love;
   for he does not afflict from his heart
      or grieve the children of men.
–Lamentations 3.31-33

Although God causes grief, it does not come from a hard or distant heart.  God does not afflict his children from his heart.  Once again, there is comfort in knowing that God grieves for me, for Amy, for our children, for our loss.  He is a compassionate God, a God full of passion and empathy for his children.  If I thought that this loss came from God’s heart for me, I would never feel safe calling on him again.  It is something I am wrestling through still.

   “I called on your name, O LORD,
      from the depths of the pit;
   you heard my plea, ‘Do not close
      your ear to my cry for help!’
   You came near when I called on you;
      you said, ‘Do not fear!’
–Lamentations 3.55-57

Why do children cry out for us at night? Why do they scream? Because in the night, in the darkness, in the shadows there are monsters.  Why do they cling so hard even when we are holding them?  Not because they aren’t convinced that we can hold them, but because they aren’t convinced that we believe them.  We spend our children’s childhoods telling them that there are no monsters.  Everything is fine.  You are going to be fine. 

One way to tell a child, don’t be afraid is to convince her that there are no monsters and so there is nothing to be afraid of.  But she knows that you can’t possibly know that.  You are either deceived or a deceiver. Because there are monsters.  There is darkness and shadows and death.  A better way to comfort her would be to remind her, “I will always come when you cry out.  I am here.  I am with you.  Don’t be afraid.”

I am still frightened.  I am definitely still in the pit.  I am trying to call to mind the truths that will restore my hope.  At least in the morning there will be steadfast love and new mercies waiting for me. 

This was the Christmas card from our first Christmas in Stafford. None of us ever knew what Ilona was doing exactly. Including Ilona.

Four Advents Later

The book of Lamentations is an interesting study in Lament. It is composed of five elegies. Not to be confused with eulogies, an elegy is a poem or song of lament. The five elegies of Lamentations are intentionally constructed.

The first two elegies (chapters 1 and 2) are acrostics, in which the first word of each verse begins with the next letter of the Hebrew Alphabet. each verse has three lines, so in English it would look like a,,2,3; b,2,3; c,2,3; etc.

Chapter 3 begins every line with the letter of the Hebrew alphabet (a,a,a; b,b,b; c,c,c; etc.).

Chapter 4 returns to the first pattern, but only has two lines in each verse (a,2; b,2; c,2; etc.).

Chapter 5, although 22 verses long (the number of letters in the Hebrew alphabet), is one line each and does not follow the Hebrew alphabet in any order. You could represent it then as a, g, r, f, d, etc.

None of this matters a whole lot, but the writer was intentional. So, why? the first four chapter give voice to the full impact and far reaching affect of grief and loss. You might say it goes form A to Z. the fifth chapter stands out in contrast. Perhaps the poet is reminding us, sometimes there is no neat order to grief. It wreaks havoc on all it contacts.

Also, Hebrew poetry often, not always, puts the main point in the center of the poem. This is called Chiastic structure (named for the X in Greek, because the poem flows into the point and back out looking a little like the side of an X). If this is so in the book of lamentations, it could be that chapter three is the central chapter and therefore the focus. If that is true, the center of chapter three would be verses 31-33 and possibly focusing on verse 33:

31 For the Lord will not
cast off forever,
32 for, though he cause grief, he will have compassion
according to the abundance of his steadfast love;
33 for he does not afflict from his heart
or grieve the children of men.

Though he cause grief, he will have compassion. The Lord does not afflict from his heart. The natural flow of the Lord’s heart is compassion, steadfast love. A bruised reed, he will not break. A smoldering candle, he will not snuff out. Come to him, you who are worn out and weary. He is gentle. You will find rest for your soul.

Also, the fact that Lamentations does not end on an up note helps the grieving reader to remember, sometimes hope waxes and wanes. Sometimes it is bright and I feel I can see a future on the horizon. Other days it is as dark as winter solstice on a cloudy day in the fog. And that is okay. God is still present, just like the sun that never went away, only the temporary dark circumstances of winter have tried to hide it. But the Sun is always shining, whether you can see it or not.

Advent Day Nineteen – Four Advents Later

A Darker Advent than Desired – Day 19

When Advent seems to bring as much heartache as joy, maybe more

How can I sing in a time like this?

   By the waters of Babylon,
      there we sat down and wept,
      when we remembered Zion.
   On the willows there
      we hung up our lyres.
   For there our captors
      required of us songs,
   and our tormentors, mirth, saying,
      “Sing us one of the songs of Zion!”
   How shall we sing the LORD’s song
      in a foreign land?
   If I forget you, O Jerusalem,
      let my right hand forget its skill!
   Let my tongue stick to the roof of my mouth,
      if I do not remember you,
   if I do not set Jerusalem
      above my highest joy!
–Psalm 137.1-6

Ours is a musical family.  We love music. We love singing together.  We love playing together.  We love watching musicals and attending concerts and finding new music.  I loved attending our kid’s choral and band concerts.  I would sit in the audience with a huge grin the entire performance.  If there was choreography involved it was lost on me, because I only had eyes for my child.

Last Christmas.

It is part of what makes advent so hard this year.  The sticky sweet songs seem like mockery.  The songs that used to bring me tears of sentimentality, now bring tears of loss and sometimes anger.  Other true advent songs are just painful.  Genuine longing for real healing and deliverance is hard to add my voice to right now.  We still listen to music in our home.  Almost exclusively songs of longing and need.  We have a playlist called, “Lord, please do not tarry.” 

The Saturday before Ilona’s death, four of us went to a Gray Havens concert.  We had dinner at a favorite restaurant of Amy and me where I introduced Ilona and Jakob to Trappist Monastery style beer and mussels.  The evening was practically perfect.  This was four days before her death.  I will treasure that night forever.

We have not been able to play Christmas music in our home yet.  My singing in church is a different kind of praise now.  It is longing.  It is pain.  It is desperation for Christ to finish what he started. Lord, please do not tarry.

I captured this on Christmas Evening 2021.

Four Advents Later

Music remains an important part of our family life. We’ve begun hosting a concert every year to offer an evening of hope for anyone who may be hurting or are looking for a night of music that runs deeper that the typical concert. We include the video above in every concert. It is the only way we can sing with Ilona still. It is always a moving part of the concert

Amy and I still struggle with Christmas music, though recently there have been more advent songs about longing and hope in the midst of hurt and loss. This one from the Porter’s Gate, who joined us for the Sunflower Concert last September, is based on Isaiah’s prophecies.

This year our church will host a “Longest Night” Advent service. On the 21st (the longest night of the year) we will have a worship service of scripture reading, song, prayer, and lament for any for whom the need at Christmas runs deeper than LEDs can address. Whether facing a loss or a broken relationship or difficulty in work or deteriorating health, there is much for which we need the light of Christ to shine.

Advent Day Eighteen – Four Advents Later

A Darker Advent than Desired – Day 18

When Advent seems to bring as much heartache as joy, maybe more

Grieving with hope is still grieving 

Devout men buried Stephen and made great lamentation over him.
–Acts 8.2

We do not want you to be uninformed, brothers, about those who are asleep, that you may not grieve as others do who have no hope.
–1 Thessalonians 4.13

When it became clear that I would not be returning to the pulpit before the end of the year, one of Hope of Christ’s elders, who is licensed to preach and also a good friend, asked what I thought he should preach on.  I suggested 1 Thessalonians.  My suggestion was entirely based on this one verse in chapter four. 

You might read this verse and assume that it means that there are two types of people in this world—those with hope and those without hope.  And while those without hope might grieve, those with hope are not to grieve.  Afterall, we have hope. We have the joy, joy, joy, joy down in our hearts… to stay.

But that is not what Paul is saying.  He is saying we don’t need to grieve without hope.  We can grieve with hope.  It is not just that Christians don’t understand that grief is a reality of this world because loss is a reality of this world.  The Greek Stoics, centuries before Christianity, believed that any strong emotion is wrong.  The average number of bereavement days granted by most US employers is four days.  That is public or private sector, Christian or non-Christian sector—four days.  Compare that to the average time it takes to begin to feel some level of normalcy after the death of a close loved one—two years.  To say that western culture and the U.S. specifically does not grasp grief is an understatement.

In Acts 8, we are told that devout men buried Stephen – who had just been stoned to death – and made great lamentation over him.  Two things to see in these descriptions. 

First, “devout men.”  These were no semi-committed Christians, nor new believers who did not quite understand the deeper truths of doctrine and death and resurrection, but devout men.  They were devoted Christians.

Second, they “made great lamentation” over Stephen.  Literally, they “made mega mourning” over him.  They grieved.  Not for Stephen.  Of course, not for Stephen.  For themselves.  For their own loss.  I know that I am not grieving for Ilona.  This is part of what it means to grieve with hope.  I grieve for myself and for Amy and for Ilona’s siblings and for her grandparents and for her aunts and uncles and cousins and friends and coworkers and church.  The mourning is great because our loss is great.

This is a particularly great lamentation season.  How do we do Christmas the way we have done it in the past?  This weekend was very hard.  We finally put up the tree Saturday.  As for most families, this is a family event.  So, the very act was hard from start to finish.  I remember walking into the living room in years past and seeing Ilona lying on the floor underneath the tree just staring up into the decorated branches and lights.  We don’t own many boxes of matching ornaments.  Every ornament on the tree has a memory, a purpose.  Amy and I could not touch a single ornament without tears. 

It is hard to celebrate the light of the birth of the Christ child with the shadow of the death of our own child looming so large, so close.  The week leading up to Christmas, which always brought eager anticipation, this year brings a certain anxious dread.  My heart breaks for my youngest daughter and new son-in-law for whom this was supposed to be only the best kind of first Christmas.  I know that this is precisely the darkness into which the light has come and from which the light has delivered me, but the lamentation is still great. 

This year, my sister bought us a smaller tree just for Ilona’s ornaments. This is not all of them, by far, but as many as we could bring ourselves to go through.

Four Advents Later

It is appropriate that this post comes up today. Over the last four advents, it has not gotten easier for Amy and me to put up the tree and decorate it. This evening, while everyone is out, I have put the two trees up. Tomorrow Amy and I will decorate them. We will weep. It will be the only thing we will get done tomorrow.

It will come up in later posts I believe, but we buy our children an ornament every year. When they were children, the ornaments definitely reflected a childlike taste and love for all things Christmas and whatever new interest they had at the time (we may or may not have a Bella and Edward ornament for one daughter). But as they grew, Amy bought them ornaments with more meaning and beauty. The goal was to present them with a box of personal, meaningful ornaments when they started their own homes and households. And so, when we decorate the tree, every ornament, even the act of getting the ornaments out, is so full of sweet memories that it is almost unbearable. We are told that one day those sweet memories will be more sweet than painful. I do not know. I hope it is true. I do know that Christmas number four is not that day.